Career Tips

Recruiter or on your own


Is it better to use a recruiter or find a job on your own?  While I have spoke with some great recruiters and then some not so good ones, I feel that they are only trying to get information out of you.  Where are the jobs open that they can try to fill, etc. 

I am in the same boat. I had someone from job.com contact me about getting my resume out to agencies (for a price). I was told there are tons of jobs that employers will only post to these agencies. She told me there are almost 3400 positions in the three categories that I was looking in. When I told her I only wanted jobs within a 30 mile radius she suddenly couldn' t tell me how many positions were available and I haven' t heard from her since. I keep viewing the jobs on monster, career builder, job.com, hotjobs.com, the state/county employment site, and LinkedIn.com. Linked In is a great networking site. You link yourself to past and present co-workers and old school mates. Check it out.

Agencies work in different ways. None of them good. Many of them unethical. The different types of agencies are temporary agencies, placement agencies, staffing agencies, headhunters. They have names that generally describe what they do but often you have to really read about what the advertisement is calling for to figure it out.

The agencies whose representatives contact a job seeker and try to sell their services are, in my opinion, con artists. They have no place in the professional world. They don't have any proven statistics regarding the industry you are seeking employment in nor do they have any actual job vacancies in their little clutches. They search the papers and job boards just like everybody else in order to find businesses who are hiring and then send your resume to them. The resume's are paid no more attention than if you had sent it yourself.

Temporary agencies offer temp jobs which can last one day to one year and temp to hire jobs which can last up to three months at which time the company has the option to hire you on as an employee. You do not work for the company but rather for the temporary agency. You are paid by the temp agency and you have to follow the rules of the agency as well as any rules set forth by the company you are working at.

Something very important to remember about temp agency is that the amount of money they pay you for working at the company is a very small fraction of the amount they are charging the company. Ie: if you are being paid $10 per hour, the company is being charged $35 or $40 per hour.

Another thing to remember is that if you turn down an assignment from a temp agency, they will put you on the bottom of their list and consider you a poor risk for employment. This regardless of the fact that the job they offered was not in the industry or within your actual job wants or needs.

Placement and Staffing agencies will generally not contact you but will contact the employer and then they will place the advertisement, review resumes, pre-screen candidates and then will set up interviews with the hiring manager. If there are any questions regarding follow up, you have to go through the agency. To go to the company itself will cause the agency to disregard any further contacts from you and they will do their damnde$t to ignore you. They will even go so far as to tell the company that you do not want the job.

Headhunters are the same as staffing and placement agencies but they are people who specialize in a specific field so are more knowledgable about what the needs are for qualifications, skills and abilities. They do, however have a certain amount of arrogance to them which makes them very hard to work with because they think everything you do is wrong and if you don't listen to them regarding what to say, do and wear, you have basically written yourself out of a job.

For the most part, agencies (all agencies) do not have the jobs available that they advertise. They only want to get people into their agencies so that they can build their list and tell the company that they are contacting that they have a number of people who would fit perfectly.

A temp agency is actually an okay place for a person just entering the workforce and wanting to get experience in a number of different entry level jobs to figure out what he/she wants to do for a career. They are not for people who already have experience doing what they want for their career or for people who have already proven themselves in their current industry and are looking for something a couple of rungs above entry level.

My personal opinion of an agency and of the people who are employed to work there is several (and I do mean SEVERAL) levels below professional, knowledgable or worthy of a job seeker's time and energy.

If someone contacts you to put your resume out there for a price that is not legit sorry.  Recruiters make their money off the clients, not the candidates

I haven' t had much luck with agencies/headhunters.  Without exaggeration more than 150 agencies/headhunters have contacted me in the past year, presenting opportunities and "requesting permission" to submit my resume.

I have had exactly three interviews in the past year via headhunters, none of whom could even follow up on simple tasks, such as providing an email address so that I could send a thank you email to the interviewer. 

My last interview arranged by a headhunter was a disaster!  The FIRST question the hiring manager asked was if I could speak Spanish (No).  The 2nd question - previous manufacturing experience (None).  End of interview. 

Actually I blame both the headhunter & the firm' s HR on for that because there was no mention of either (Ability to speak Spanish or prior manufacturing experience) in the job description.  Additionally, if those are actually job requirements, the headhunter and/or HR is responsible for pre-screening candidates to determine if the candidates have the requisite skills/abilities.

Not one of those 150+ agencies/headhunters is a repeat ' presenter' .  That is, not once has any agency/headhunter, after presenting one opportunity, has ever presented a second position - even though I follow up with the headhunters.  Many of these are MAJOR agencies, such as Robert Half, Nauticus, RHO, etc.

If anyone knows of a reputable, reliable headhunter, please forward me that headhunter' s information.

Career Tips

  1. Interview Tips
  2. Resume Tips
  3. Salary Tips
  4. Career Change Tips
  5. Job Search Tips
  6. Career Tips

© Rights Reserved. Career, Resume, Interiview Tips | Sitemap